[2026-11-02] SELECTION RECORD — sauna / KIHD (maintainer challenge: mikesbalance.com blog on Finnish sauna data)

  • (1) Query: blog’s cited papers checked by hand against the registry (no web search); then openalex search on the BMC Med 2018 title (auto-logged above).
  • (2) Results: Laukkanen 2015 JAMA IM — HELD (Sauna Bathing and Cardiovascular Mortality; blog’s HRs match). Kunutsor 2017, Kunutsor 2018 — same KIHD cohort + group, not independent of the held paper. Laukkanen 2018 BMC Med (10.1186/s12916-018-1198-0; 1688 men AND women, age 53-74, 51.4% women, median 15.0 y follow-up) — previously CUT in rejected-sources.md as single-cohort / healthy-user confounded.
  • (3) Adjudication: Laukkanen 2018 BMC Med — SELECTED (re-admitted, reversing the earlier cut). Reason: the held page states the evidence covers men only; this paper extends the same cohort to women and an older age band (stratum extension, route (a)/(b) transport question), NOT independent replication — same cohort, same group, so never type-E backing. Kunutsor 2017/2018 — REJECTED (same cohort; no new stratum).
  • (4) Acquisition: Laukkanen 2018 fetched OA via openalex -> inbox/ (14 pp, text-native). Next: process inbox (strike the rejected-sources row with a reversal note), then a delegated ingest onto Sauna Bathing and Cardiovascular Mortality.

[2026-11-03] SELECTION RECORD — Purcell 2014 supplementary appendix (maintainer: acquire if material)

  • (1) Query: direct fetch, no search. Channel bin/fetch_browser.py local Chromium, then --service steel, target the Lancet Diabetes & Endocrinology article page (DOI 10.1016/S2213-8587(14)70200-1) to reach the supplementary appendix link.
  • (2) Results: local Chromium HTTP 403; Steel HTTP 402 (Payment Required — service account, not a literature result). No appendix URL obtained. Zero = tool/access artefact, not absence.
  • (3) Adjudication: SELECTED as material. The held paper puts the intention-to-treat results (Table 2 rows) and the appetite ratings in the appendix; the wiki’s pace verdict rests on “no three-year weight for all starters is held” and on the appetite-ratings population being unstated. Whether the appendix ITT covers all starters or only phase-2 entrants is not known until read.
  • (4) Acquisition: BLOCKED -> maintainer-drop requested (appendix PDF to inbox/). No substitute source sought.
  • [2026-11-04] openalex search “daily self-weighing and adverse psychological outcomes randomized controlled trial” -> 1 hits: https://doi.org/10.17615/becq-gy58
  • [2026-11-04] openalex search “2013 AHA/ACC/TOS guideline for the management of overweight and obesity in adults” -> 4 hits: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jacc.2013.11.004; https://doi.org/10.1161/01.cir.0000437739.71477.ee; https://doi.org/10.1331/japha.2014.14502; https://doi.org/10.3904/kjm.2014.87.2.136
  • [2026-11-04] openalex search “behavioral self-regulation for weight loss in young adults randomized controlled trial” -> 1 hits: https://doi.org/10.1186/1479-5868-6-10
  • [2026-11-04] openalex search “daily self-weighing adverse psychological outcomes” -> 2 hits: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.amepre.2013.08.006; https://doi.org/10.17615/becq-gy58
  • [2026-11-04] openalex resolve “10.1016/j.amepre.2013.08.006” -> 1 hits: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.amepre.2013.08.006

[2026-11-04] SELECTION RECORD — Self-Weighing primaries (open thread from the Self-Weighing weave: Steinberg 2014, Jensen 2014, Gokee-LaRose 2009)

  • Query/channel: openalex title searches (logged above): Steinberg daily self-weighing psychological outcomes; 2013 AHA/ACC/TOS obesity guideline; Gokee-LaRose behavioral self-regulation young adults.
  • SELECTED Steinberg - Daily Self-Weighing Psychological Outcomes RCT 2014 -> 10.1016/j.amepre.2013.08.006 (AJPM journal version; settles the Madigan-vs-Zheng between-group psychological result). The UNC repository copy 10.17615/becq-gy58 is the same paper (OA author copy) — acceptable PDF source, not a separate work.
  • SELECTED Gokee-LaRose 2009 -> 10.1186/1479-5868-6-10 (IJBNPA, OA; settles the comparison-arm [AMBIGUOUS] on Self-Weighing for Weight Loss).
  • SELECTED Jensen 2014 (2013 AHA/ACC/TOS guideline) -> 10.1161/01.cir.0000437739.71477.ee (Circulation, OA); currently held secondhand only. REJECTED as duplicate prints: 10.1016/j.jacc.2013.11.004 (JACC co-publication), 10.1331/japha.2014.14502 (reprint), 10.3904/kjm.2014.87.2.136 (Korean review of it).
  • Acquisition-requested: all three listed to the maintainer 2026-11-04; not fetched (no fetch requested in this pass).
  • [2026-11-04] openalex search “clinical effects of regular dry sauna bathing systematic review” -> 1 hits: https://doi.org/10.1155/2018/1857413
  • [2026-11-04] openalex resolve “10.1161/01.cir.0000437739.71477.ee” -> 1 hits: https://doi.org/10.1161/01.cir.0000437739.71477.ee
  • [2026-11-04] openalex resolve “10.1056/NEJMoa0801369” -> 1 hits: https://doi.org/10.1056/nejmoa0801369
  • [2026-11-04] openalex resolve “10.1016/S0140-6736(02)11600-X” -> 1 hits: https://doi.org/10.1016/s0140-6736(02)11600-x
  • [2026-11-04] openalex search “SCORE2-OP risk prediction algorithms estimating 10-year risk cardiovascular disease older persons” -> 0 hits: (none)
  • [2026-11-04] openalex search “SCORE2-OP” -> 6 hits: https://doi.org/10.1093/eurheartj/ehab312; https://doi.org/10.1093/eurjpc/zwac176; https://doi.org/10.3390/jcm13071931; https://doi.org/10.1007/s00277-023-05556-0; https://doi.org/10.3389/fcvm.2024.1509240

[2026-11-04] SELECTION RECORD — process inbox (maintainer drop) + rejected-source registration

  • Acquisition status for the Self-Weighing primaries record above: all three arrived as maintainer-drops. Jensen STAGED (raw/binary/papers/); Steinberg STAGED DEFERRED (awaits-ledger 2026-10-29 stands); Gokee-LaRose CUT pre-ingest (n=40; would only settle how Zheng 2014 reports its comparison arm).
  • Hussain 2018 (10.1155/2018/1857413), maintainer-drop: screened pre-ingest for the sauna independence gap. REJECTED: its only mortality cohort is KIHD (held Laukkanen 2015); the rest are small trials, many in heart failure (treatment, out of scope).
  • Duplicates of held binaries: Ekelund 2026, Zhang 2026, Purcell 2014 (byte-identical); Lang 2024 (final issue print of the held epub-ahead copy, same text) -> inbox/_duplicates/.
  • Query/channel (registration only, no acquisition): openalex resolve 10.1056/NEJMoa0801369 (HYVET) and 10.1016/S0140-6736(02)11600-X (PROSPER); openalex search "SCORE2-OP" -> 6 hits, SELECTED 10.1093/eurheartj/ehab312 as the algorithm paper (the other 5 are applications/extensions, not registered). The earlier title-phrase query for it returned 0 (title.search strictness, not literature absence). Author lists via the OpenAlex works API. All three stay REJECTED (rejected-sources.md); registry rows added so a re-drop is caught. ATEMPT (ISRCTN17647940): registered as a [NOT YET HELD] placeholder, trial in progress, nothing to acquire.

[2026-11-04] SELECTION RECORD — supplementary appendices of held sources (manual channel)

[2026-11-04] SELECTION RECORD — discover (sweep 10: full refresh, Engine G rows 47-58, pool delta)

  • Query/channel: discover.py --refresh --write (engines A-F + coverage matrix via OpenAlex, --no-log); acq_contradiction.py --rows 47..58 --write (auto-logged above); reader-agent hand queries, 80 openalex.py search lines plus 11 forward-cite walks (openalex.py cites <lighthouse doi> --goldish) of each row’s lighthouse, auto-logged above. No auto-log: abstract pulls through the OpenAlex works API (abstract_inverted_index, best_oa_location) and the Europe PMC REST search, by the reader and by the parent re-pull (12 DOIs: Kjaergaard, Thomsen, Stens, Banach, Ding 2025, Liddle, Wu, Lauersen 2018, Singh, Díaz Goñi, Fernández-González, Takeuchi), plus the parent’s pool-delta reads (Edwards, Eisa, Nikkhah, Onagbiye, Bourke).
  • Results: Engine G 53 unheld candidates on 9 rows, zero-hit rows 49, 54, 56 (title.search strictness: rephrasings found the held sources). Reader zeros: CRF -> cancer incidence MA (>=2023) and an osteoporosis-exercise umbrella read as literature absences; every other zero was strictness. Takeuchi 2024 has no abstract in OpenAlex or Europe PMC. Pool delta vs the committed pools: Engine A +8, Engine E +19. All 23 quoted abstract phrases re-located by the parent.
  • Adjudication: SELECTED Edwards 2023 (HIGH), Kjaergaard 2024 (MED-HIGH), Liddle 2023 and Wu 2024 (MED), Takeuchi 2024 (MED, unread), Eisa 2026 (MED), Díaz Goñi 2026 (LOW). DEFERRED Singh 2024, Stens 2023, Banach 2023, Lauersen 2018, Afonso 2025 (preprint). REJECTED Thomsen 2023 (scope: exercise during systemic cancer treatment, as Bettariga), Fernández-González 2026 (concurs; established-fracture edge), Ding 2025 and Pelland 2025 (cuts stand), Nunez-Cortes 2022, Nunes 2024, Oliveira 2024, Poon 2024, Ekelund 2018 and the other sitting MAs, USPSTF 2024, Sibley 2020, Bricca 2020, Yan 2025, Onagbiye 2023, Nikkhah 2025, Bourke 2024, the Boushey NESR pattern SRs, the off-topic coupling hits. Reasons per paper: contradiction-hunt.md sweep 10.
  • Acquisition-requested: none fetched in this pass. OA routes: Edwards (BMJ PDF), Wu (Springer PDF), Díaz Goñi (Nature PDF), Liddle (Teesside repository), Kjaergaard (PMC12012764). Maintainer-drop: Takeuchi 2024, Eisa 2026.
  • [2026-11-04] openalex fetch “10.1136/bjsports-2022-106503 10.1007/s40279-024-01993-7 10.1038/s44220-026-00599-4 10.1007/s40279-023-01950-w 10.1210/clinem/dgae393” -> 0 hits: (none)
  • [2026-11-04] sweep-10 OA fetch (acquisition update to the record above). openalex.py fetch on the five OA routes: Wu 2024 (Springer PDF, 19pp) and Díaz Goñi 2026 (Nature PDF, 18pp) -> inbox/, first pages verified. Edwards 2023: OpenAlex pdf_url and local fetch_browser.py --download both returned the BMJ article HTML page, not a PDF (deleted; no paper HTML). Kjaergaard 2024: Europe PMC fullTextXML -> HTTP 500 (not in the OA XML subset); europepmc.org/articles/PMC12012764?pdf=render -> 403 (curl and local Chromium). Liddle 2023: OpenAlex has no PDF; the Teesside repository’s accepted manuscript (research.tees.ac.uk/files/62554152/...pdf) -> 403 (curl and local Chromium). Maintainer-drop: Edwards, Kjaergaard, Liddle, plus the paywalled Takeuchi 2024 and Eisa 2026.

[2026-11-04] SELECTION RECORD — process inbox (sweep-10 folds; maintainer drop + manual supplement fetch)

  • Query: no search. Manual channel (hand-logged): one direct fetch of the Edwards 2023 BJSM supplement at https://bjsm.bmj.com/content/bjsports/57/20/1317/DC1/embed/inline-supplementary-material-1.pdf (the BMJ DC1 pattern), after the main text arrived without a league table.
  • Results: HTTP 200, 44pp PDF (Tables S5-S14: SUCRA and node-split network contrasts with CrIs). Maintainer drop: Edwards 2023 main text (11pp), Eisa 2026 (10pp), Liddle 2023 accepted manuscript (36pp). Already in inbox/ from the OA fetch: Wu 2024, Díaz Goñi 2026.
  • Adjudication: all six STAGED to raw/binary/papers/ with gold registry rows (the appendix as its own <slug> Appendix row, same work as the parent, never type-E against it). Plan-queue #28 verdicts: INGEST 37-41, DEFER 42 (Díaz Goñi: no decision flips; G recorded). None cut.
  • Acquisition-requested: still maintainer-drop: Kjaergaard 2024 (10.1210/clinem/dgae393) and Takeuchi 2024 (10.1007/s11332-024-01213-9).
  • [2026-11-05] openalex search “Pagonas isometric handgrip aerobic hypertension” -> 0 hits: (none)
  • [2026-11-05] openalex search “home-based isometric handgrip endurance training hypertension” -> 0 hits: (none)
  • [2026-11-05] openalex search “Healthy weight loss maintenance with exercise liraglutide or both combined” -> 3 hits: https://doi.org/10.1056/nejmoa2028198; https://doi.org/10.1056/nejmc2109509; https://doi.org/10.3410/f.740056883.793591402
  • [2026-11-05] openalex search “Aerobic versus isometric handgrip exercise in hypertension” -> 2 hits: https://doi.org/10.1097/hjh.0000000000001445; https://doi.org/10.1097/hjh.0000000000001566
  • [2026-11-05] openalex search “comparing home-based isometric handgrip exercise versus endurance training for blood pressure management” -> 1 hits: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jash.2018.01.007
  • [2026-11-05] openalex fetch “10.1016/j.jash.2018.01.007” -> 0 hits: (none)
  • [2026-11-05] openalex fetch “10.1056/NEJMoa2028198” -> 0 hits: (none)

[2026-11-05] SELECTION RECORD — DOI resolution for the Gate 62 maintainer-acquisition items

Query (1). OpenAlex search (title, no type filter), five queries plus two fetch calls, listed in the auto-log lines just above. Targets: Pagonas 2017 and Goessler 2018 (the direct isometric-handgrip-in-hypertension trials, Gate 62 corrective 6) and Lundgren 2021 (S-LiTE, exercise vs liraglutide vs both for weight-loss maintenance).

Results (2). The two paraphrased queries (Pagonas isometric handgrip aerobic hypertension, home-based isometric handgrip endurance training hypertension) returned 0. Attribution: a tool artifact (OpenAlex title-search strictness on paraphrase), not literature absence. Both trials are cited by Edwards (refs 62 and 63); re-querying with the exact titles from that reference list (located with srcgrep.py) returned each trial first.

Adjudication (3).

  • SELECTED 10.1097/HJH.0000000000001445 — Pagonas, J Hypertens 2017;35:2199-2206. The trial itself.
  • REJECTED 10.1097/hjh.0000000000001566 — a commentary on Pagonas in the same journal, not the trial.
  • SELECTED 10.1016/j.jash.2018.01.007 — Goessler, J Am Soc Hypertens 2018. The trial itself.
  • SELECTED 10.1056/NEJMoa2028198 — Lundgren, NEJM 2021;384:1719-1730. The trial itself.
  • REJECTED 10.1056/nejmc2109509 — correspondence on Lundgren, not the trial.
  • REJECTED 10.3410/f.740056883.793591402 — a Faculty Opinions recommendation entry, not the trial.

DOIs written into the three placeholder registry rows (sources.md, rows still [NOT YET HELD]).

Acquisition (4).

  • Goessler: FETCHED to inbox/ (accepted manuscript, KU Leuven Lirias repository, 25 pp). Awaits process inbox.
  • Pagonas: no OA copy found; paywalled -> maintainer-drop.
  • Lundgren: openalex fetch HTTPError; fetch_browser.py --download HTTP 403 (NEJM bot wall, not defeated) -> maintainer-drop, URL handed to the maintainer.

[2026-11-05] SELECTION RECORD — process inbox (Gate 62 acquisition items)

Query (1) / results (2). No new search; intake of the three trials resolved in the record above.

Adjudication (3).

  • SELECTED, STAGED Pagonas - Aerobic vs Isometric Handgrip Hypertension RCT 2017 (maintainer drop, published J Hypertens PDF, 8pp). 3-arm RCT, n=75 hypertensives. Tier moderate [downgrade: small single RCT], admitted by override as the direct head-to-head test the indirect Edwards network lacks.
  • SELECTED, STAGED Goessler - Isometric Handgrip vs Endurance Training RCT 2018 (self-fetched AAM). Correction to the record above and to the registry placeholder: the population is 60 healthy adults (mean BP 126.9/84.7), not hypertensives, so it bears on the normal/high-normal stratum. Tier moderate, override as for Pagonas.
  • SELECTED, STAGED Lundgren - Exercise Liraglutide Weight Loss Maintenance 2021 (maintainer drop, published NEJM PDF, 12pp). 4-arm RCT, n=195; lean mass reported in the main paper’s tables. Tier high. Supplementary Appendix not held.

Acquisition (4). All three in raw/binary/papers/. Kjaergaard 2024 and Takeuchi 2024: maintainer could not obtain; parked (see ingest-queue.md block I).

[2026-11-06] SELECTION RECORD — S-LiTE Supplementary Appendix (parent cold-audit C1)

Query (1). No search; direct fetch of the NEJM supplement for 10.1056/NEJMoa2028198 via fetch_browser.py --download, URL https://www.nejm.org/doi/suppl/10.1056/NEJMoa2028198/suppl_file/nejmoa2028198_appendix.pdf (NEJM supplement pattern).

Results (2). HTTP 403 (NEJM bot wall, same as the main paper on 2026-11-05). Not defeated.

Adjudication (3). SELECTED Lundgren - Exercise Liraglutide Weight Loss Maintenance 2021 Appendix (placeholder row, [NOT YET HELD]): the paper states end points without hypotheses, lean mass among them, are reported with 95% CIs, and the held main text prints SE bars only, so the lean intervals the flip test on GLP-1 and Lean Mass needs are probably there. Also holds Tables S7-S10 and the RAND-36 physical-functioning values by arm.

Acquisition (4). Blocked -> maintainer-drop, URL handed to the maintainer.

[2026-11-06] SELECTION RECORD — process inbox (Carlson 2016, S-LiTE appendix)

Query (1) / results (2). No new search; maintainer drops answering the Carlson [AWAITS] (Goessler ref 23) and the appendix request in the record above.

Adjudication (3).

  • SELECTED, STAGED Carlson - Isometric Handgrip Training RCT 2016 (Medicine 2016;95:e5791, DOI 10.1097/MD.0000000000005791, OA, 7pp). 2-arm RCT, n=40 hypertensives, 30% vs 5% MVC. Tier moderate [downgrade: tiny-n], admitted by override as the second sham-controlled handgrip trial. Lineage note: last author Smart co-wrote the Cornelissen & Smart 2013 MA that Goessler builds on.
  • SELECTED, STAGED Lundgren - Exercise Liraglutide Weight Loss Maintenance 2021 Appendix (NEJM supplement, 39pp). Tier high, same work as the held main paper.

Acquisition (4). Both in raw/binary/papers/. The NEJM 403 above is resolved by the maintainer drop.